Are u a real R+ Fan?

Sujet: Are u a real R+ Fan? Jeu 27 Mar 2008 - 7:55

Well, hypothetically talking...

Imagine that one of the R+'s member go out of the group and it's replace by another person...

Will u keep being a R+ Fan?

_________________

Sujet: Re: Are u a real R+ Fan? Jeu 27 Mar 2008 - 12:00

hmm, hard question.
I think that when the new member will arrive, I will hate him, but I will listen the music, just to see if anything is changing.
If the music is good, I will follow the band, but with regrets of the past.

But, if it's Till who stop Rammstein, I will not follow the band, because the voice can't be fake by someone else.
_________________

Sujet: Re: Are u a real R+ Fan? Jeu 27 Mar 2008 - 15:41

All depends of what you mean about "Real fan".

I am not a real fan, because I listen occasionaly Rammstein (rarely, I'd say) and I don't listen to they CDs anymore.

Anyway, even when the Beatles stopped playing, a lot of fans continued to listen to their music, and even today ! It's the same thing with Nirvana, and Rammstein is popular all around the world (even if they are less than 3 years ago).

But if a new member came to replace the one who left, I wouldn't care, because I am not as keen on Rammstein as I was 3 years ago. I would listen Rammstein just like a band of my childhood, but that wouldn't mean I'd stay a fan.

So, if you want a precise answer of the question, NO, I am not a real fan.

Sujet: Re: Are u a real R+ Fan? Jeu 27 Mar 2008 - 18:01

Of course ! I like rammstein for the music not for the member. I think about Megadeth, Metallica, Scorpion or Emperor who the member was changing very often. But everybody like them for the music they do.

V.I.P Age : 16 Inscrit le : 24 Juin 2007 Messages : 2122

But Rammstein won't continue if a member leaves the band. They've always been saying that they can't change any member.

Sujet: Re: Are u a real R+ Fan? Jeu 27 Mar 2008 - 22:25

We're imaging if they do.

Sujet: Re: Are u a real R+ Fan? Ven 28 Mar 2008 - 18:45

V.I.P Age : 16 Inscrit le : 24 Juin 2007 Messages : 2122

no, I don't think so..or if they do, they'd lose all their success...the actual members have the "Spirit Rammstein" and make the soul of the band, an eventual new member would waste all.

Sujet: Re: Are u a real R+ Fan? Sam 29 Mar 2008 - 12:42

I'll keep listening too !
_________________
Article 1 /!\ :
Dunkyz a toujours raison .

Article 2 /!\ :
Au cas où Dunkyz aurait tort ,se référer à l'article 1 Smile

http://youtube.com/watch?v=zfwWgHi7gok

V.I.P Age : 16 Inscrit le : 24 Juin 2007 Messages : 2122

Not a lot. Each band has his identity, and don't want to lose it. But the buisness is more important than the music, see. After that Tarja had been expelled from Nightwish, the band was censed to be splitted.

And do you know why they didn't stop ? Because of the money. Because they were too successful, that they could lose all their money and success by stopping Nightwish.

Now, with the new singer, a lot of fans are left, but the band is always successful, and they don't risk to lose their money.

Replace Nightwuish by Rammstein (and all the bands you know, whatever their opinions about this topic), and it's the same thing. One member left, Rammstein would say "We stop !", but they will realized that it will be too complicate. And if they do a solo carreeer, will they have the same success ?

So it's more useful to stay together with a new member instead of doing solo career, even if a lot of fans will leave.

V.I.P Age : 16 Inscrit le : 24 Juin 2007 Messages : 2122

It's the same for AC/DC, when Bon Scott died, he's been replaced by Brian Jonhson, and I would they have more success with Brian than they had with Bon.
But Paul said "Rammstein ist Rammstein" so...
And the members are all the same since the beginning, hte only time a member has been replaced was when Paul has been replacedf by Daron Malakian, and it wasn't in a big concert but in a small apparition in the Pledge of Allegiance tour, where they played eight songs.

Rammstein ist rammstein.

Money is money.

Very Happy

V.I.P Age : 16 Inscrit le : 24 Juin 2007 Messages : 2122

I don't see the interest to compare a metal band with a president...

Admin Inscrit le : 31 Jan 2005 Messages : 6555 Localisation : Bretagne

Paul said that :

Das Modell will be including in Lichtspielhaus
We will find all the Reise, Reise videos on Volkerball

and much more
_________________

V.I.P Age : 16 Inscrit le : 24 Juin 2007 Messages : 2122

OK, so just 2 words :
Wait & See...

Lol, yeah !

Paul is known to say informations, which are in fact false Rolling Eyes

that's a hard question,i never thought about it,not really,i'm with Rammstein couz the music,of course,but the members are R+,are music,probably if some of then leave the band will lose the personality,directly affecting the sound,mostly Till...for me it's impossible without Till,comercially everthing is possible,since the money is the only thing who matters,but not for me,definitely,so i don't know what would be my reaction it that happens.

Admin Inscrit le : 31 Jan 2005 Messages : 6555 Localisation : Bretagne

I share you opinion
_________________

A lot of fans would left if they changed one of the members.

It's the same thing for Nightwish. They replaced Tarja by Anette, and now, it's totally different, and a lot of fans don't want to keep listening anymore ! But Nightiwsh stood Nightwish anyway.

V.I.P Age : 16 Inscrit le : 24 Juin 2007 Messages : 2122

Nightwish had already changed one member (the bassist) in 2001, and Rammstein won't change, because they all six had the same diffulties to begin, it was too hard to make music in eastern Germany. They started together, they'll stay together.

Admin Inscrit le : 31 Jan 2005 Messages : 6555 Localisation : Bretagne

The topic is not about reality .. Everybody knows "Rammstein, Together, Forever" but we can imagine ...
_________________

That's what everybody says. The little girls always say; "Yeah, we will be best friends forever, we won't leave us whatever the situations !", and then they are splitted and meet other people, who they make again their life with.

Replace the little girls by Rammstein (and eveybody), it's the same thing.